Thanks to Bob Ryan, Dave Sims, Alex Obermeyer, Kyle Smith, Donald Goldblatt & Henry Black for adding names. Columbia has most (my list & I went there); Brown the least.
They had to have stayed at an Ivy school for at least 2 years (Lou Gehrig) and their pro careers had to have been at least 3-5 years.( That eliminated several people, but I left in Jeremy Lin because I assume his career will continue).

Sid Luckman- Columbia
Lou Gehrig- Columbia
Jack Molinas- Columbia
Jim McMillian- Columbia
Eddie Collins- Columbia
Gene Larkin- Columbia
Marcellus Wiley- Columbia
George Starke- Columbia
Marty Domres- Columbia
Lou Bender- Columbia
Ed Marinaro- Cornell
Ken Dryden- Cornell
Joe Nieuwendyk- Cornell
Kevin Boothe- Cornell
Gary Wood- Cornell
Pete Gogolak- Cornell
Matt Birk- Harvard
Ryan Fitzpatrick- Harvard
Pat McInally- Harvard
Jeremy Lin- Harvard
Ted Donato- Harvard
James Blake- Harvard
Armond Hill- Princeton
Bill Bradley- Princeton
Geoff Petrie- Princeton
Charlie Gogolak- Princeton
Chris Young- Princeton
Will Venable- Princeton
Moe Berg- Princeton
Brian Taylor- Princeton
Chris Dudley- Yale
Calvin Hill- Yale
Gary Fencik- Yale
Dick Jauron- Yale
Mike Pyle- Yale
Eric Johnson- Yale
Chuck Bednarik- Pennsylvania
Corky Calhoun- Pennsylvania
Ernie Beck- Pennsylvania
Mark DeRosa- Pennsylvania
Joe Valerio- Pennsylvania
Matt Mahoney- Pennsylvania
Reggie Williams- Dartmouth
Nick Lowery- Dartmouth
Rudy LaRusso- Dartmouth
Jay Fiedler- Dartmouth
Brad Ausmus- Dartmouth
Steve Jordan- Brown
Zak DeOssie- Brown
Bill Almon- Brown
Sid Luckman- Columbia
Lou Gehrig- Columbia
Jack Molinas- Columbia
Jim McMillian- Columbia
Eddie Collins- Columbia
Gene Larkin- Columbia
Marcellus Wiley- Columbia
George Starke- Columbia
Marty Domres- Columbia
Lou Bender- Columbia
Ed Marinaro- Cornell
Ken Dryden- Cornell
Joe Nieuwendyk- Cornell
Kevin Boothe- Cornell
Gary Wood- Cornell
Pete Gogolak- Cornell
Matt Birk- Harvard
Ryan Fitzpatrick- Harvard
Pat McInally- Harvard
Jeremy Lin- Harvard
Ted Donato- Harvard
James Blake- Harvard
Armond Hill- Princeton
Bill Bradley- Princeton
Geoff Petrie- Princeton
Charlie Gogolak- Princeton
Chris Young- Princeton
Will Venable- Princeton
Moe Berg- Princeton
Brian Taylor- Princeton
Chris Dudley- Yale
Calvin Hill- Yale
Gary Fencik- Yale
Dick Jauron- Yale
Mike Pyle- Yale
Eric Johnson- Yale
Chuck Bednarik- Pennsylvania
Corky Calhoun- Pennsylvania
Ernie Beck- Pennsylvania
Mark DeRosa- Pennsylvania
Joe Valerio- Pennsylvania
Matt Mahoney- Pennsylvania
Reggie Williams- Dartmouth
Nick Lowery- Dartmouth
Rudy LaRusso- Dartmouth
Jay Fiedler- Dartmouth
Brad Ausmus- Dartmouth
Steve Jordan- Brown
Zak DeOssie- Brown
Bill Almon- Brown
Comments